PDA

View Full Version : Harry Potter: Spoil Us Not!


lisas3575
06-25-2007, 11:04 AM
This weekend there was a thread with the subject of "Harry Potter spoilers". I didn't open it (didn't look like many did) so I can't comment on what was in there. It did, though, make me want to discuss how flippin' mad I'm going to be if anyone here does spoil the book, the last book, where all the fans will get answers to the questions we've had for years and years. Please, please, let those of us enjoy the story as it's meant to unfold. Be clear in your posts and thread titles if you're going to post information that may ruin the fun for those of us who haven't read it yet, or risk the worst bat-bogey hex ever unleashed outside of Hogwarts. Of the thread over the weekend, I was grateful that the poster was clear about what possibly was inside so I knew I didn't want to open that thread.

The following is an editorial posted by Melissa over at The Leaky Cauldron (http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/2007/4/28/spoil-us-not-sneaks-a-refresher-on-leaky-s-pre-book-policy), and I thought it was great:

OK peoples. It's just about that time: A few months away from the book. THE book. We're getting a lot of e-mails about spoilers - and not just the kind where you say, "You may not want to read my theory because it's totally a spoiler." Thanks for the warning - we had no idea Snape was a body surfer! Awesome!
Anyway, the books will soon be printed. Sometime in the next few weeks we'll hear all sorts of ridiculous things, such as:

* The book magically appeared in a field ("Phoenix": Remember how the person who found it just happened to call the ever-magnanimous tab "The Sun," who then printed a review that basically read, "Nanny-nanny-poo-poo, we've read it and you haven't"?).
* Or, a bunch of bets for Harry to live / for Harry to die came out of the town where the books are being printed ("Half-Blood Prince": Remember the bets on Dumbly?).
* Even, perhaps, that there was a pistol shootout / watergun showdown / spaghetti-slinging match over stolen copies (again, "Half-Blood Prince." That is, just the pistol part).

And then there are the little spoiler-zone pockets, which crop up in strange places. Last time, a big leak came from a librarian who decided to dig in a few days early and post the results on her journal. Bookstore workers have also been responsible for leaks (though, we understand how working in a store where unopened Potters lurk evilly can be a form of torture acceptable in old-school Salem). Before HBP's release, someone on a military base in Malaysia got hold of the book and scanned in every first chapter page, the summary, and the whole final chapter, and sent it to Leaky. Some staffers were intensely spoiled. Some staffers are still bitter. Some staffers curse this person's name.

The powers that be seem even more prepared for this spoiler scenario this time. There are talks of extreme security measures, of chains and locks and last-minute deliveries.

BRING IT, we say.

Here it is, a refresher on Leaky's spoiler policy:

Ahem.

DON'T DO IT.

Sending us spoilers will get you one place, bucko: sent to Scholastic, Christopher Little, Bloomsbury, and every JoLawyer we can think of. We don't want to see them, we won't post them, and we'd want to stop you. Book revelations aren't to be spurted out in bullet form on a message board. They're to be read, dispersed at the proper moment, given all the context of the story. This is not like the movies, which cannot contain real plot surprises for fans.

If Harry dies, we don't want to know about it until J.K. Rowling decides to tell us. And if you decide to tell us before that, you'll incur the wrath of a staff of almost 200, most of whom have been waiting almost 10 years for these final revelations and can NEVER get back the moment you rob by spoiling them. That's some wrath, right there. We own pitchforks, hot wax and feathers. And we're not afraid to use them.

If, between now and July 21, Jo or her people release a fact about the book, it will be posted on this site, but you will be heavily warned about it beforehand. We understand a lot of you want to remain super-pure from now until then. We admire you, oh white angels.

If it comes from ANYWHERE else - from ANY unofficial source - it will not be on this site. You have no need to worry. We might recognize its existence in a news story, but the actual content of the spoilage won't appear on these pages.

So, bookstore managers, librarians, and people who like to stroll in the fields next to the publishing plants: We appreciate that you feel the need to share your revelations with us. But you'd have better luck and would get a better response if you told your goldfish instead. Watch out, though - we hear the publishing companies are looking into fishbowl surveillance. Mr. FlippityFins just may be a plant.

And if you're that guy who shouted "SNAPE KILLS DUMBLEDORE!" outside the bookshop at 12:01 a.m. on July 16, 2005? Just go away, man. Just go away. Quietly. And we won't hurt you.

Seriously: we're almost there, guys, so let's make sure we respect every other Harry Potter fan we can. It'll be worth it!

KristiB
06-25-2007, 11:17 AM
Until the book is published and on the shelves I think of "spoilers" as speculations.

If I were the publishers I'd be planting all kinds of mis-nformation. :D

No matter what someone tells me about Harry's demise or non-demise or the meaning of it all I'm still going to buy and read the book and enjoy it as I'm sure others will too.

testkitchen45
06-25-2007, 11:31 AM
Until the book is published and on the shelves I think of "spoilers" as speculations.

If I were the publishers I'd be planting all kinds of mis-nformation. :D

No matter what someone tells me about Harry's demise or non-demise or the meaning of it all I'm still going to buy and read the book and enjoy it as I'm sure others will too.

I plan on buying the book as soon as I can on the 21st, & reading it as quickly as makes sense, with my fingers plugging my ears & me singing "nana nana boo boo; I can't hear you!" :D No headlines; no TV news or newspaper reviews; nothing--I hope I can escape a spoiler once it comes out, b/c it'll probably be the real thing at that point.

And if Rowling kills off Harry, I think she had better go into seclusion! ;) :p

sneezles
06-25-2007, 11:42 AM
Molli's thread contained a link to a "spoiler" nothing she wrote could be considered one. I didn't read the link just commented that spoilers won't spoil the pleasure I'll get from reading every word of the book. And it is after all, just a book though while enjoyable I wouldn't get my knickers in a wad if I happen to read a spoiler.

little_bopeep
06-25-2007, 11:51 AM
I did read the spoilers, and part of them were plausible. Well, face it...all spoilers are plausible unless they involve dead people that can't come back to life. It would be sad if one of these things came to pass, but that's just the way it goes. There's one speculation that I found to be really intruiging, so I really want to see if that's really in the book or not. :cool: :cool:

SheRa
06-25-2007, 12:00 PM
i got into the series late and got all the books in paperback form. so my worry is now that i've been all caught up, the paperback won't be out until who knows when, and someone will ruin the ending for me. i don't want to buy ONE hardcover, and i know the library will be dry for the first few weeks at least. so i'm hoping one of my VERY loyal HP friends will buy the book, read it quickly, and then let me borrow it. i want my set of books to match, darn it! :cool:

Lrimerman
06-25-2007, 12:30 PM
Shera,

I would buy the hardcover, you can always buy the paperback later for your collection and put the hardcover up on paperbackswap.com and get another book for it, or donate it to the library, etc.

I can't wait for the book to come out. We are going camping that weekend, so I plan to meet my sister to get my copy (she pre-ordered them) and read at the campground!!

Lisa

ClaraB
06-25-2007, 12:44 PM
I pre-ordered mine from Amazon, but I was too cheap to pay for shipping :o :p , so I'm going to have to wait a few days for mine. I plan on going into seclusion until I get my copy :D .

CompassRose
06-25-2007, 12:52 PM
Personally, I feel that if the only exciting thing about a book or movie is what happens in the end, I'm not going to bother reading it. Spoilers don't bug me -- what's the big deal? Isn't one reading it for the entire experience, the writing, the character development, the incidents and events?

I knew, for instance, perfectly well "the twist" of the Sixth Sense, but it was still a good movie. And I knew that Dumbledore died well before I got around to reading the last Harry. But I suppose I might be an oddity of some kind.

LaraW
06-25-2007, 01:41 PM
I pre-ordered mine from Amazon, but I was too cheap to pay for shipping :o :p , so I'm going to have to wait a few days for mine. I plan on going into seclusion until I get my copy :D .

Clara, I pre-ordered and didn't pay for shipping either, but I did the same thing last time and my book was in my mailbox on the release date. It was a nice surprise.

lindrusso
06-25-2007, 09:49 PM
Personally, I feel that if the only exciting thing about a book or movie is what happens in the end, I'm not going to bother reading it. Spoilers don't bug me -- what's the big deal? Isn't one reading it for the entire experience, the writing, the character development, the incidents and events?

I knew, for instance, perfectly well "the twist" of the Sixth Sense, but it was still a good movie. And I knew that Dumbledore died well before I got around to reading the last Harry. But I suppose I might be an oddity of some kind.

For me, it depends, but mostly I don't like knowing the ending.

I'd still enjoy HP even if I knew what happened, but I want to find out on my own and read the book without any prior knowledge that will then shape everything word I read. Things that are meant to be misleading won't be. Things that are meant to tease, won't. Suspensful scenes will be disminished, etc., etc.

I did not know the ending of the Sixth Sense and was delighted that I never found out - it really made for a GREAT surprise at the end. Even better - it was a lot of fun to go back and watch to see how I could have possibly missed the truth through the whole movie. I don't think it would have had nearly the power or the mystery if I had known and I'm so glad I didn't.

Grace
06-25-2007, 10:42 PM
I agree with you, Alysha. I have looked forward to the release of each and every book. They are each great stories on their own, with suprises and suprise endings in each one. It's not like I have slogged through six books just to finally reach the end of book seven.

And I have read all the Harry Potter books two or three times over already. So of course, I know the endings of them all now, so the mystery and suspense are gone, but I still re-read them with great enjoyment. The thrill of reading the first time is only one kind of enjoyment. The subsequent reads give me a different sort of enjoyment. I can look for the details, "see" things I didn't see before, focus on the subplots, etc., that may have whizzed by me the first time through in my excitement to find out what happens next.....

Molli526
06-26-2007, 12:47 PM
If you haven't ordered, Amazon has a great deal now. $17.99 plus a $5 coupon for later, once the book has shipped!

I ordered with super saver shipping for #6 and it still came the day of release. This year I have Prime, so I expect it to be here day of release as well.

gertdog
06-26-2007, 01:12 PM
Most of you on this thread can imagine my devastation when I realized that, on July 21, I will be attending my cousin's wedding instead of madly devouring the last HP. I won't even be home when my pre-ordered copy arrives- will have to pick one up in California and read on the plane on the 22nd.

CR, I see what you mean about reading for the entire experience, and I feel that way about some books. Other books I choose specifically because they're in the mystery/suspense genre, because I want to be engaged in guessing and figuring out and having my theories change as the plot progresses. Or I want to be caught up in the emotion that the author creates, rather than anticipating feeling a certain way because I already know what's going to happen. I've loved the HP books- I know not everyone does- but I want to savor every moment of the last one, and I want the story to emerge as I read, rather than reading with the knowledge that the plot is taking me to a specific place. :)

KimKelly
06-26-2007, 10:02 PM
I pre-ordered mine from Amazon, but I was too cheap to pay for shipping :o :p , so I'm going to have to wait a few days for mine. I plan on going into seclusion until I get my copy :D .

OOhhh... I didn't think of that. I did the "free super saver shipping". Does that mean I don't have the guaranteed delivery? I may have to cancel and make my way to Costco....

Kim

KristiB
06-27-2007, 07:12 AM
Most of you on this thread can imagine my devastation when I realized that, on July 21, I will be attending my cousin's wedding instead of madly devouring the last HP. I won't even be home when my pre-ordered copy arrives- will have to pick one up in California and read on the plane on the 22nd.



Can your cousin change the date? :D ;)

ClaraB
06-27-2007, 07:39 AM
OOhhh... I didn't think of that. I did the "free super saver shipping". Does that mean I don't have the guaranteed delivery? I may have to cancel and make my way to Costco....

Kim
Nope - you had to choose standard shipping to get guaranteed delivery. You might get lucky and get it on the 21st anyway - a couple of other posters indicated that happened to them with HBP. I'm keeping my fingers crossed!

KimKelly
06-27-2007, 08:28 AM
Thanks ClaraB! I actually cancelled it last night and I'll just go to Costco that morning. I would be so bummed if I didn't have it that day. My son got a laugh out of that... "What's the big deal?" he said. Although he is just as excited as I am and we'll read much of it together.

As for spoilers... I actually read the spoilers last time to find out who it was that died. But then I have trouble waiting for Christmas too.... so I guess that is me. I always like to find out the end of a movie too so I'll know if I will like it or not. My husband would never want to see spoilers though. And as for Christmas..... he could wait till New Years for his presents and not really mind! Acutally, I wonder if her just does that to bug the rest of us! :p

We sure are looking forward to the release!

Kim