Question re Reviews

[Donna P]

I am fairly new here - but have been making many of the CL recipes from the last three months. I would like to give some reviews. My questions is -- should I search for prior reviews and post mine there or start a new post with a bunch of miscellaneous reviews? My opinion as a poster is to do reviews in one post, my opinion as a reader would be to have all reviews of a particular recipe in one post.

What is your opinion?????

[This message has been edited by Donna P (edited 04-14-2001).]

[SoCal]

Welcome Donna! In my opinion, I would just start a new post. I certainly appreciate any and all reviews and I'm sure everyone else does too!!

Review away! Can't wait. http://www.cookinglight.com/bbs/biggrin.gif

[This message has been edited by SoCal (edited 04-14-2001).]

[valchemist]

That's a good question Donna...thoughtful of you to think of the readers as you did.

It is nice to have a lot of reviews for the same recipe in one post because it makes it easier to compare reviews and determine what substitutions/alterations should or could be made to the particular recipe.

And it is also nice for you, as the poster, to see what others have said so that you can provide input on a particular problem that someone might have experienced with the recipe.

That being said, no one would mind if you put your reviews in a separate post. It happens all the time. Any reviews are always welcome, in any form!

Valerie

[SusieO]

We'll take 'em any way you've got 'em. Welcome to the BB!

[schuh]

Donna P, I'd just post new postings if I were you. I've found in searching for old posts that I get a fair amount of error messages for some reason. I'd save yourself the trouble. I love reading reviews, no matter how they are posted!