PDA

View Full Version : Review: Carrot-Ginger Soup (4/01)


makedah
04-01-2001, 12:52 PM
Some of my disappointment is probably due to pilot error. I like thicker, more savory soups. This recipe didn't call out to me, I tried it to use up some carrots I had on hand -- that may also be why I wasn't impressed.

I think I used too much broth, and probably cooked the mixture too long. This recipe is easy enough and the spice mixture is interesting -- kind of Indian/Middle Eastern. However, I found this to be too weak/watery of a soup. You may want to puree the whole recipe instead of just 2/3, as the recipe recommends. A cream of some sort -- or more pureed potatoes -- may give it more substance. It didn't taste BAD, it just wasn't my style. My sense is that if you use a veggie broth it would make a nice vegetarian soup.

misstapioca
04-09-2001, 11:32 PM
what can i say...yummm
i liked this soup alot. it tasted comforting and i loved the ginger flavor, which was subtle. It reminds me of a couple soups from last year(yellow bell pepper bisque and the butternut squash soup).

chefbec
04-10-2001, 09:34 PM
Yes, we had this at our last CL dinner, and it was excellent. It was nice and thick. Perhaps you should try it again...

JJ40
04-11-2001, 09:02 AM
Just my two cents...I enjoyed this soup. I particularly liked the flavour the spices added.

Julie

Peggy
04-17-2001, 09:05 PM
We had this for dinner tonight and everyone liked it. After reading makedah's comments, I decided to puree the entire soup which made it nice and thick. I thought the seasoning were excellent! I like this recipe better than my old stand-by, so from now on when the mood calls for carrot soup, this will be it!

Peggy

Personal Chef
11-20-2001, 06:20 PM
What is this soup supposed to taste like? I've never had carrot soup before so I'm unsure if I made it correctly. I followed the recipe (except used jarred sliced ginger) but I can't really taste any of the spices. To me, this supposed is VERY mild in flavor. Is that the way it's supposed to be?